What Windows Phone 7 (WP7) Device (mobile phone) to buy?

Currently i am wondering about buying a new Phone.

As an enthusiastic game programmer with some years of experience with XNA and C# my choice would be WP7.

I could now spend some time discussing the pros and cons of WP7 vs. Android vs. iOS, but i won’t. The short answer is, that iPhone is too expensive and i do  not know enough about Android programming. That might change in the future but right now i feel that i simply want a WP7 device. No hard reasons for that, just curiosity and the great price of course.

So after browsing some friendly electronic discounter around the corner i narrowed it down to two possibilities.

The Samsung Omnia 7 and the LG Optimus 7.

The cheapest WP7 phone at the moment is the HTC 7 Trophy. You can get it a low as $238. But this phone is not available worldwide. It seems to be aimed at the european market. So if you can get it for such great price where you live, it is an alternative. It is just a WP7 phone, that meats all requirements and does nothing really wrong, but at the same time nothing really amazing.

Price:

Please note, that these are not the amazon.com prices but the cheapest offer i found around.
Samsung Omnia 7: 318$
LG Optimus: 253$
The difference in price is about 65$ in favor of the LG Optimus 7. So one point to the Optimus 7.

Memory:

The Omnia comes with 8GB or 16GB. I am talking about the 8GB version here.
Samsung Omnia 7: 8GB
LG Optimus: 14GB
The next point for the Optimus 7.

Display:

Okay, here wins the Samsung Omnia 7 Super AMOLED display, no arguments: Point to Samsung.
I could write more about how good this display is, but let me say just this: If the display is the most important part for you -> Buy the Omnia 7.

Size:

138g and 122,6mm height for Samasung.
158g and 125mm height for the LG.
I carry my phone around in my pocket so this is a point for the Samsung Omnia 7.

Special features:

The LG is to this time the only WP7 phone that has augmentet reality features implementet. So if you like this stuff it is a pretty good reason to get the Optimus 7.
The Omnia7 is lacking here. It has got its really great display, and a slightly better camera that the LG (at least that is what tests show).
As all of this is a question of personal preferences i will not award a point. You should decide for yourself what is important to you in a mobile phone.

Conclusion:

It’s a draw. Well of course i knew it would end like this. If one of the phones would be the obviously winner there would be not need for this post.

And now? Well in the end everybody have to decide for oneself but i would certainly appreciate your input on this. Do you own a WP7 phone? Are you planning to buy one? Leave your input in the comments.
Currently i am leaning towards the Omnia 7.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: